When Good Intentions Backfire: Understanding the Cobra Effect in Communities

[StevenM]

Ever tried to fix a problem, only to realize your solution made things worse? That’s the Cobra Effect in action. The term comes from a story in colonial India, where a bounty for dead cobras led to people farming cobras instead. When the bounty was canceled, they released the snakes, and the problem got even worse. The Cobra Effect is all about how rewards or incentives can backfire.

For online communities, it’s easy to see how this can happen. Think about offering incentives for user engagement—like rewards for posting frequently. Suddenly, you might find users spamming the forums with low-quality posts just to earn those points. Or, what if a new rule to reduce negativity leads to users finding loopholes and expressing their frustration in other, more subtle ways?

How can community managers create positive incentives without falling into the Cobra Effect trap? What are some examples where a reward system has worked well, or where it’s backfired? Let’s share ideas on balancing incentives and keeping community goals on track.

View full article